“Screw You” Evangelism

It’s one thing for enthusiastic believers to want to talk about their religion. After all, people who are enthusiastic about a new band, or restaurant, or investment want to share the good news with their friends and family members ­— even with perfect strangers, if they’re excited enough. And I’m always glad when someone I respect takes the trouble to recommend a good mechanic, or insurance plan, or exercise regimen.

In fact, I always scratch my head when people say they don’t want to hear about someone else’s enthusiasms. Really? You think what you’ve got can’t possibly be improved upon?

Stranger still, some people get actually offended when someone else suggests a better alternative, whether it’s a hair stylist, or automobile, or diet. I mean, are you so conceited or defensive that you wouldn’t rather trade up when you can?

But some zealots go way too far.Bad enough to have someone pretend to be interested in you when they just want to rope you into a pyramid scheme in the guise of a “business opportunity.” At least it makes a certain selfish sense for them to do so. But what about religious zealots who push their beliefs on you in the face of certain resistance? What in the world are they doing?

Recently, a small Christian church in Toronto has decided to take the old tradition of “street preaching” quite literally. They’re not just preaching in public, rather than in church. Such preaching has a long heritage, of course, strange as it still strikes most of us today. John Wesley, George Whitefield, and other 18th century preachers were forbidden from preaching their message to the poor in established churches, so they took their message to crossroads, homes, and other places where their audiences could hear them.

No, this weird little group in Toronto decided to preach literally in the middle of a residential street. They claim that it is their right to do so, and probably it is. But it is indeed a weird thing to do, given that the chances of anyone actually being attracted to, let alone being persuaded by, this group are remote indeed. Why would they do it?

Perhaps they hope that God will work a miracle and convert someone. But my experience with such people (and I grew up around some of them) is that their attitude is centrally one of doing their duty: Christ commanded us to preach the gospel and, by God, we’re going to do it, whether anyone else likes it or not.

Of course, Christ did command Christians to preach the gospel, but if such people would check their Bibles a little more thoroughly, they would find, in the last chapter of the first gospel (Matthew), that Christ more particularly called the Church to “make disciples.” This means to actually facilitate people becoming Christians: not just to hurl the Christian message at them like a brick, but instead to invite them into a conversation such that they would eventually be so enamored of Christ that they, too, would want to follow him as Lord.

This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.

In the face of the neighbours’ evident resentment and in the presence of apparently no interested audience, this group defiantly vows to keep at it. And one might ask, to keep at what? Doing your duty, scoring points with your conscience and what you imagine is God, and confirming your membership in the One True Faith. What’s not happening, however, is anyone being made a disciple of Jesus.

I’m reminded of Jehovah’s Witnesses, plodding from house to house or standing stonily on street corners handing out their tracts. It literally doesn’t matter if they make any converts. They’re putting in their time, checking off their boxes, in order to qualify among the elite 144,000 they believe the Bible prophesies will get the best goodies in the world to come.

We can all sense pretty quickly the difference between someone generously offering us a gift and someone using us to score points.

I ask my fellow Christians, in the name of the gospel, to please knock it off.

Originally published by The National Post here.

0 Responses to ““Screw You” Evangelism”

  1. Jeff Loach

    That’s a good article, John. I wonder if many who engage in this kind of ‘Molotov Cocktail’ evangelism simply don’t *know* to do otherwise? As you say, “It’s our duty,” etc., but is their culture such that nothing else will do? To be sure, most who take up this kind of faith-sharing would not be equipped to apologize for the faith with your ability (or that of some other equally gifted apologists and writers), so perhaps it’s their only tool.

    Not that this makes it any better or more effective, of course. But we don’t see many people with more than a high school education doing street evangelism. (That’s not politically correct, I know, fellow reader, so prove to me that it ain’t true.) Is education – good theological education, from college/seminary, pulpit and Sunday school classroom/small group living room – a possible antidote to brick-lobbing for Jesus?

    Just wonderin’.

  2. Ryan

    Great article, John. I particularly like this statement:

    “We can all sense pretty quickly the difference between someone generously offering us a gift and someone using us to score points.”

    In my experience, people’s radar is very well tuned to this crucial difference. Nobody likes to be seen as a potential notch on someone’s evangelism belt. This story out of Toronto is a good reminder to keep doing the theological work to help people understand evangelism as gift giving as opposed to scoring points.

    (I like the title of your post better than the NP article :))

  3. David Alexander

    It makes it really hard to like the fact that just maybe the Gospel is being preached even we we distain the method…But this goes too far.

    No wonder Christians get a bad name. I too wish those who feel this is good judgement would just stop it…

  4. Josh Mueller

    Linda at “kingdom grace” has a good series with probing questions on Christian marketing strategies right now. Her blog can be found here:


    I think what needs to be discussed more is not only obnoxious manners of trying to spread the gospel but also a general disregard towards people in evangelistic attempts of both the past and present. If human beings are seen as nothing but objects of a conversion agenda, we need not be surprised that less and less people show up or show interest, even when invited in a much more pleasant manner.

    I would dare to say that at the root is a deficient understanding of the gospel itself and what it means to show love to people.

  5. Shannon

    Mr Stackhouse I have sent you a letter in regard to this!…But I am Quite Shocked at Your “comment” !.. You say Your a Christian?.. have you read the part of the bible the gospel of matthew 7:16, You will know them by their fruits!..

    My Dear Sir

    Steert Evangelism.. is the best way to witness to people who do not Know Jesus as their Personal Savior!… I do not know why you are picking on Christians? but believe me when I say this YOU WILL STAND BEFORE GOD ALMIGHTY AND GIVE A ACCOUNT FOR WHAT YOU DID OR DID’MT DO!!!.. To Give you some advice seek out the Lord and ask HIS forgiveness!.. for if you don’t… well you know what will happen!

  6. Shannon

    Also for the Threads I have on read this blog..Christians have always got a bad rap.. from every one!!.. from the dawn of time itself!… but believe me folks when I say Judgement day is Coming!!!… and those who Mock Christians Mock GOD ALMIGHTY TOO!… I would Strongly Suggest to the people that posted their thoughts on this web blog..seek out GOD before It Is To Late!…

  7. Ron

    Preach it, Shannon! Prof Stackhouse, you are guilty of approaching this issue with far too much common sense, for which the God Shannon and I worship would surely be displeased. Surely the Lord looks with disfavor upon winsome evangelism, and will reserve the most severe punishment for the cowards who refuse to browbeat the infidel.


Comments are closed.